Feedback, rejection, and self-doubt don’t define you. Here’s how to approach them with confidence and clarity.
As writers, we often see ourselves as creators and leave the role of judgment to others—agents, editors, critics, and readers. But what if we gave ourselves permission to take back that authority?
I recently came across a quote from Tara Mohr’s Playing Big that shifted my perspective:
“That day, I wrote because I am a woman who loves writing. And I did something I can best describe as taking back the authority around my own work. Before that day, I thought of myself as the writer, and of those people out there as the judges of that writing. I suddenly saw that I could join them as a judge of my work, that I had the right—as much as they did—to look at my writing and determine what I thought was good, what needed improvement, what I was proud of.”
This resonated deeply with me because it reminded me that as writers, we are not just creators—we’re also capable judges of our own work. Here’s what I’ve learned about navigating feedback, rejection, and self-doubt while maintaining confidence in your writing.
Reclaiming Authority Over Your Work
One of the most empowering things you can do as a writer is to evaluate your own work with pride and self-confidence. It’s easy to view feedback and criticism as the ultimate measure of your writing’s worth, but your opinion matters just as much as anyone else’s.
- Shift your mindset: You’re not just the creator of your stories—you’re also their first and most important editor and evaluator.
- Love your draft, love your idea, even when others don’t. Your current creativity and your creative vision both have value, and every draft brings you closer to the story you’re trying to tell.
- Confidence doesn’t mean your work is perfect; it means you trust your ability to grow and improve.
Feedback as Neutral Data
Feedback can feel personal, but at its core, it’s just data—a tool to help you refine your work and better connect with your audience.
As Tara Mohr writes in Playing Big, “Feedback is just data. It is meant to give you tactical information about how to reach the people you want to reach. It can’t tell you about your merit or worthiness.”
I find this perspective liberating. Feedback isn’t about you as a person or even about your talent—it’s about understanding what resonates with your audience. This shift in perspective allows you to focus on your readers’ needs rather than taking critiques personally. For example, during developmental edits, I create a specific category for ‘reader expectations.’ This helps me tailor the feedback I receive to the unique preferences of the genre and audience I’m writing for, ensuring the story connects with the people it’s meant to reach.
When you think of feedback this way, it becomes a tool, not a judgment. Use it to refine your craft and strengthen your connection to the readers you want to reach.
Handling Rejection Sensitivity
Rejection is a natural part of the creative process, but that doesn’t make it easy to handle. One way to reframe rejection is to think of it as a step forward, not a failure.
A friend of mine makes it a habit to submit to “reach” opportunities—places where she knows rejection is likely but where success could open new doors. She does this intentionally to address her rejection sensitivity, which many creatives experience.
Rejection sensitivity is the heightened emotional response to rejection or even the anticipation of it. For writers, this can lead to self-doubt, fear of sharing work, or avoiding opportunities altogether.
To combat this, treat rejection as a skill to be practiced. By regularly submitting to “reach” opportunities, you can yourself to view rejection as a natural part of the growth process rather than a reflection of your worth or ability.
When you think about it, rejection is unavoidable in any creative profession. Not every pitch will land, not every story will resonate, and not every opportunity will come through. But that’s okay.
Rejection provides clarity: it tells us where we need to improve, where we might need to refine our approach, or even where we should double down on our unique strengths. And sometimes, rejection is simply about timing or fit—factors that have nothing to do with the quality of your work.
By normalizing rejection and intentionally making it part of your growth process, you not only build resilience but increase your chances of success. Every “no” becomes another step closer to the right “yes.”
However, it’s important to be mindful of what I call “fledgling projects.” These are new, fragile ideas or projects that might need more nurturing before being exposed to external feedback. Protect these tender beginnings until they’re strong enough to stand on their own, then you can send them out into the world.
Evaluating Feedback Sources
Not all feedback is created equal. Its value depends largely on who is giving it and whether it aligns with your creative goals. Feedback, whether invited or unsolicited, can shape your work in meaningful ways—but only if it’s coming from the right source.
When assessing feedback, take a moment to reflect on these key questions:
- Is this feedback from your target audience or an ideal reader? Feedback from someone outside your intended audience may not resonate with your vision or goals, and that’s perfectly okay. Consider whether their perspective aligns with the readers you’re trying to reach or the story you’re trying to tell.
- Do you respect the person giving feedback, and would you want to collaborate with them? If you wouldn’t trust their instincts or share creative synergy with them, their advice might not be worth acting on. Reflect on whether their input enhances your creative process or simply distracts from it.
- Does the feedback align with your goals for the project? Not every suggestion will fit the vision you have for your work. Stay true to your intentions, and don’t feel pressured to incorporate feedback that takes your story in a direction you don’t believe in.
By thoughtfully evaluating the source of feedback, you can prioritize advice that supports your creative growth while staying grounded in your vision.
Loving Your Work Through It All
At the end of the day, writing is deeply personal, and navigating feedback, rejection, and self-doubt is part of the process. But you have the power to take back your authority over your work.
Love your story, even if it’s imperfect. Love your writing, even when others may not understand it. Embrace feedback as a tool, not a judgment. And trust yourself to know what’s best for your story.
Your voice matters, and your story deserves to be told—on your terms.
Join the Author’s Atlas for More Insights
Subscribe here and get your free copy of our writing workbook Penning Your Novel: The Essential Pillars of Storytelling.
